155,157 registered members
Search Now
     
Home Health
Topics
Features/
Opinion
Health
Calculators
Health
Clinics
Find a
Professional
Medical
Q&As
Discussions Online
Video
Immunisation
Tracker
Rate My
Hospital
Welcome to irishhealth.com (19 Jun, 2013) Quickfind
Printer Friendly Version Add to your scrapbook Email to a friend
 

ADVERTISEMENT



Depression pills' value exaggerated

[Posted: Mon 21/01/2008 www.irishhealth.com]

Antidepressants are far less effective than doctors and the public may have been led to believe, a new study has claimed.

Eighty-eight per cent of clinical trials that showed the drugs were less than effective either were not published in medical journals or were presented as positive findings, according to the study in the New England Journal of Medicine.

The researchers examined the studies that drug companies submitted to the Food and Drug Administration in the United States when they were seeking regulatory approval for 12 antidepressants.

The drugs were all approved between 1981 and 2004, and are now widely prescribed.

It was found that all but one of the 38 positive studies given to the FDA were published, but most of the negative studies were not published.

A doctor reading the medical journals would think that individual antidepressants were between 11- and 69-per-cent more effective than they really are, according to Prof Erick Turner, of Oregon Health and Science University, who is lead author on the paper.

He said it is not that antidepressants do not work, but that their effectiveness has been exaggerated.
 

  PatFitzer  Posted: 04/07/2009 04:12

Once again we have a situation where it's cheeper to hand out pills (S.S.R.I.'s) etc. than it is to treat the cause of the proplem.  Most causes of depression are enviornmental/cognivive in origin.

As a society if we eacknowledged this, we might have to rethink where we are heading as a society.

Medication used in conjunction with mental health support (Psychology, Psychotherapy, Counselling) etc has been proven to be of greater long term benefit to patients, than just medication on its own.  What happens when the Doctor weans the patient off the medication when the patient has stabilised.  The problems that were causing the anxiety are still there and all the old habits/problems return, so we try another typy of medication and the poor patient finds themselves classified/pigeonholed for life.

Early intervention, continuing support and genuine empathy can go a long way in helping the patient to feel less isolated and become a productive members of society and so feel valued. Because its when a human feels useless, undervalued, and that no one cares is when depression becomes pathalogical.

 
  buzz  Posted: 06/07/2009 17:02

It is typical of our healthcare system (and indeed not exclusive to our country). Treat the symptoms as they appear, whatever you do dont treat the cause, you might have to dig deeper or work harder. Regardless of the ailment most people leave doctors surgeries with prescriptions for either antiB's or pred, or a letter passing your problem on to someone else aka a referral.

 
 
To join the discussion, register by clicking here
This website is certified by Health On the Net Foundation. Click to verify.
Copyright © 2013. All rights reserved. We subscribe to the principles of the Health On the Net Foundation